Clayface: 7 Great Comics To Read Before Watching The Batman Villain’s New Movie

Batman One Bad Day Clayface

Batman has one of the deepest rogues galleries in comics history, and one of the most popular, too. And Clayface might not be the most famous on the list, but that doesn’t make him less fascinating. His tragic backstory, shape-shifting abilities, and body horror potential make him outshine many other, more popular villains. With people comparing the movie to this year’s Obsession, it’ll definitely be another banger.

Clayface follows Matt Hagen, a rising Hollywood star who gets disfigured and turns to a risky procedure that mutates his body. Comic readers might notice that’s actually more similar to Basil Karlo’s backstory, the original Clayface. But the movie takes inspiration from both characters, creating something new for everyone. 

If you want to know all about the five major Clayfaces (yes, there are that many) and their rich history before watching the movie, we have the perfect comic list for you.

Detective Comics #40 (1940)

Detective Comics #40 (1940)

Writer: Bill Finger

Artist: Bob Kane, Jerry Robinson

This is Clayface’s origin story, and he was quite a different character back then. Without any powers or a monstrous appearance, Basil Karlo killed people because Hollywood was shooting a movie remake without him. Still, it’s a fun whodunnit comic that serves as the basis for the character’s modern iteration.

Detective Comics, Volume 1: Rise of the Batmen

Detective Comics, Volume 1: Rise of the Batmen

Writer: James Tynion IV

Artist: Eddy Barrows, Eber Ferreira

Tynion creates a new Batman team to protect Gotham, including Batwoman, Robin, Spoiler, Orphan, and Clayface. It’s a new status quo for the character, but it works amazingly. He’s funny but also quite vulnerable. With time, he truly feels like part of the team, forging a touching friendship with Orphan. Also, the Annual #1 is a great, personal retelling of his origin.

Batman: One Bad Day – Clayface

Batman: One Bad Day – Clayface

Writer: Jackson Lanzing, Collin Kelly

Artist: Xermánico

Following the “one bad day” motto from The Killing Joke, Clayface narrates one day that summarizes his life. It’s the perfect mix of gorgeous, impactful art style and relatable, visceral character writing. It’s one of the best Clayface stories in every aspect, and it’s perfect for both new and longtime fans.

The Mud Pack (Detective Comics #604-607)

Writer: Alan Grant

Artist: Norm Breyfogle, Steven Mitchell

Basil Karlo is the main Clayface, but he isn’t the only one. The Mud Pack unites all four versions of the characters, with a plan to finally drive Batman over the edge. Even if you’re not familiar with them, this story’s great at highlighting what sets them apart, be it their personality, desires, or powers. It’s a very fun comic and the only time we see all four together.

Joker’s Asylum II: Clayface #1

Writer: Kevin Shinick

Artist: Kelley Jones

A short one-issue story that goes into the core of the character. Like many Batman villains, you sympathize with him at first, but he just becomes more twisted by the minute. Kelley Jones’ artwork is what makes this stand out. His Clayface feels like an intimidating monster, and his Batman is also amazing.

A Piece of You (Wonder Woman #160-161)

Writer: Brian K. Vaughan

Artist: Scott Kolins, Dan Panosian

We can never forget that Clayface is also a very goofy character. In fact, this story plays off the goofiness of other characters too, such as Wonder Woman, who was made from clay. So, Clayface wants to absorb her and gain a power boost. It’s an incredibly silly concept that works due to Vaughan’s exciting, funny writing.

Clayface: Celebrity Dirt

Clayface: Celebrity Dirt #1 cover

Writer: Jude Ellison S. Doyle

Artist: Fran Galán

Celebrity Dirt spins the villain’s strongest ability against himself. Clayface escapes Arkham to prove he’s Basil Karlo and ready for the spotlight, despite his doctor insisting he’s Todd Russell, another version of the character. He’s right, Basil Karlo is ready to be a star again, but someone else is already using that name in several recent Hollywood movies. Is our protagonist truly who he says he is? Who is Basil Karlo? And with so many people who can be anyone, so many Clayfaces out there, how can they prove who they really are?

Comic Book Club Live Info:

Want to watch Comic Book Club live? We stream every Tuesday at 7 p.m. ET on YouTube and Twitch. Come hang out, and ask questions of our guests (and us!). And you could potentially win a $25 gift card to Midtown Comics. You can check out a current list of upcoming guests and other live appearances on our Shows page.


Discover more from Comic Book Club

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.